هل العدد الذي يقول واتبعهم الي دان محرف تكوين 41: Holy_bible_1 الشبهة مع سياق النصوص المختلفة מ א ות, ו י ר ד ף, ע ד-ד ן

Size: px

Start display at page:

Download "هل العدد الذي يقول واتبعهم الي دان محرف تكوين 41: Holy_bible_1 الشبهة مع سياق النصوص المختلفة מ א ות, ו י ר ד ף, ע ד-ד ן"

Nicholas Banks
5 years ago
Views:

1 هل العدد الذي يقول واتبعهم الي دان 41 محرف تكوين 41: Holy_bible_1 الشبهة التحريف لتحديث النص ليبدو أكثر موائمة وفهما وهو أن يقوم الناسخ بتحديث بيانات ومعلومات قديمة في النص يبدو مفهوما اكثر ومتوافقا أكثر مع سياق النصوص المختلفة 41 : ومثال ذلك ما جاء 41 في تكوين כ י אב ר ם, ו י ש מ ע ו י ר ק אח יו; נ ש ב ה א ת-ח נ יכ יו י ל יד י ב ית ו, ש מ נ ה וש לש ע ש ר מ א ות, ו י ר ד ף, ע ד-ד ן

2 ف ل م ا س م ع أ ب ر ام أ ن أ خ اه س ب ي ج ر غ ل م ان ه ال م ت م ر ن ين و ل د ان ب ي ت ه ث ال ث م ئ ة و ث م ان ي ة ع ش ر و ت ب ع ه م إ ل ى د ان. برغم ان مدينة دان لم تسمى بهذا اإلسم اال بعد فترة طويلة ومتأخرة عن هذا الوقت تحديد خالل فترة حكم يشوع بن نون فلم تسمى بهذا االسم في وقت سيدنا اب ارهيم على االطالق سفر يشوع االصحاح التاسع عشر 14 ו י צ א ג ב ול-ב נ י-ד ן, מ ה ם; ו י ע ל ו ב נ י-ד ן ו י ל ח מ ו ע ם-ל ש ם ו י ל כ ד ו א ות ה ו י כ ו ל פ י-ח ר ב,ו י ר ש ו א ות ה ו י ש ב ו ב ה, ו י ק ר א ו ל ל ש ם ד ן,כ ש ם ד ן א ב יה ם. ت خ م ب ن ي د ان م ن ه م و ص ع د ب ن و د ان و ح ار ب وا ل ش م و أ خ ذ وه ا و ض ر ب وه ا ب ح د الس ي 14 و خ ر ج و م ل ك وه ا و س ك ن وه ا و د ع و ا ل ش م د ان ك اس م د ان أ ب يه م ف א ות ה الرد في البداية ما هو الدليل على ما يدعيه المشكك هل يمتلك المشكك مخطوطة واحدة كتبت ان اب ارم ذهب الي اسم اخر غير دان هل يمتلك مخطوطة واحدة تقول ان اسم دان تغير بالتحديث لو لم يكن يمتلك هذا الدليل فهو كالعادة مدلس. ذلك فكل الترجمات باللغات المختلفة كتبت دان ولم اجد ترجمة كتبت اسم اخر اقدم من دان ومثال على

3 سفر التكوين 41 Genesis 14:14 ( SVD )فلما سمع اب ارم ان اخاه سبي جر غلمانه المتمرنين ولدان بيته ثالث مئة وثمانية عشر وتبعهم الى دان. (ACV) And when Abram heard that his brother was taken captive, he led forth his trained men, born in his house, three hundred and eighteen, and pursued as far as Dan. (AESV Torah) When Abram heard that his relative was taken captive, he led forth his trained men, born in his house, three hundred and eighteen, and pursued as far as Dan. (AKJ) And when Abram heard that his brother was taken captive, he armed his trained servants, born in his own house, three hundred and eighteen, and pursued them to Dan.

4 (ASV) And when Abram heard that his brother was taken captive, he led forth his trained men, born in his house, three hundred and eighteen, and pursued as far as Dan. (BBE) And Abram, hearing that his brother's son had been made a prisoner, took a band of his trained men, three hundred and eighteen of them, sons of his house, and went after them as far as Dan. (VW) And when Abram heard that his brother was taken captive, he led out his trained three hundred and eighteen who were born in his own house, and went in pursuit as far as Dan. (Bishops) When Abram hearde that his brother was taken, he armed his exercised [seruauntes] whiche were borne in his owne house, three hundreth & eyghteen, and folowed on them vntyll Dan.

5 (Brenton) And Abram having heard that Lot his nephew had been taken captive, numbered his own home-born servants three hundred and eighteen, and pursued after them to Dan. (CEV) that his nephew Lot had been taken away. Three hundred eighteen of Abram's servants were fighting men, so he took them and followed the enemy as far north as the city of Dan. (CJB) When Avram heard that his nephew had been taken captive, he led out his trained men, who had been born in his house, 318 of them, and went in pursuit as far as Dan. (CLV) And hearing is Abram that Lot, his brother, is captured. And numbering is he those dedicated to him, born in his household, three hundred and eighteen, and is pursuing them as far as Dan.

6 (Darby) And Abram heard that his brother was taken captive; and he led out his trained servants, born in his house, three hundred and eighteen, and pursued them as far as Dan. (DRB) Which when Abram had heard, to wit, that his brother Lot was taken, he numbered of the servants born in his house, three hundred and eighteen, well appointed: and pursued them to Dan. (ESV) When Abram heard that his kinsman had been taken captive, he led forth his trained men, born in his house, 318 of them, and went in pursuit as far as Dan. (ERV) When Abram learned that Lot was captured, he called all of his family together. There were 318 trained soldiers. He led the men and chased the enemy all the way to the town of Dan.

7 (FDB) Et Abram apprit que son frère avait été emmené captif, et il mit en campagne ses hommes exercés, trois cent dix-huit hommes, nés dans sa maison, et poursuivit les rois jusqu'à Dan; (FLS) Dès qu'abram eut appris que son frère avait été fait prisonnier, il arma trois cent dix-huit de ses plus braves serviteurs, nés dans sa maison, et il poursuivit les rois jusqu'à Dan. (GEB) Und als Abram hörte, daß sein Bruder gefangen weggeführt war, ließ er seine Geübten, seine Hausgeborenen, ausrücken, dreihundertachtzehn Mann, und jagte ihnen nach bis Dan. (Geneva) When Abram heard that his brother was taken, he brought forth of them that were borne and brought vp in his house, three hundreth and eighteene, and pursued them vnto Dan.

8 (GLB) Als nun Abram hörte, daß sein Bruder gefangen war, wappnete er seine Knechte, dreihundertundachtzehn, in seinem Hause geboren, und jagte ihnen nach bis gen Dan (GNB) When Abram heard that his nephew had been captured, he called together all the fighting men in his camp, 318 in all, and pursued the four kings all the way to Dan. (GSB) Als nun Abram hörte, daß sein Bruderssohn gefangen sei, bewaffnete er seine erprobten Knechte, dreihundertundachtzehn, die in seinem Hause geboren waren, und jagte jenen nach bis gen Dan, (GW) When Abram heard that his nephew had been captured, he armed his 318 trained men, born in his own household, and pursued the four kings all the way to Dan.

9 (HCSB-r) When Abram heard that his relative had been taken prisoner, he assembled his 318 trained men, born in his household, and they went in pursuit as far as Dan. (HNV) When Avram heard that his relative was taken captive, he led forth his trained men, born in his house, three hundred and eighteen, and pursued as far as Dan. (csb) When Abram heard that his relative had been taken prisoner, he assembled his 318 trained men, born in his household, and they went in pursuit as far as Dan. (IAV) And when Abram heard that his brother was taken captive, he armed his trained servants, born in his own house, three hundred and eighteen, and pursued them unto Dan.

10 (ISRAV) And when Abram heard that his brother was taken captive, he armed his trained servants, born in his own house, three hundred and eighteen, and pursued them unto Dan. (JPS) And when Abram heard that his brother was taken captive, he led forth his trained men, born in his house, three hundred and eighteen, and pursued as far as Dan. (KJ2000) And when Abram heard that his brother was taken captive, he armed his trained servants, born in his own house, three hundred and eighteen, and pursued them unto Dan. (KJV) And when Abram heard that his brother was taken captive, he armed his trained servants, born in his own house, three hundred and eighteen, and pursued them unto Dan.

11 (KJV-1611) And when Abram heard that his brother was taken captiue, he armed his trained seruants borne in his owne house, three hundred and eighteene, and pursued them vnto Dan. (KJV21) And when Abram heard that his brother was taken captive, he armed his trained servants, born in his own house (three hundred and eighteen), and pursued them unto Dan. (KJVA) And when Abram heard that his brother was taken captive, he armed his trained servants, born in his own house, three hundred and eighteen, and pursued them unto Dan. (LBP) And when Abram heard that his nephew had been taken captive, he armed his young men, born in his own house, three hundred and eighteen, and pursued the raiders as far as Dan.

12 (LITV) And when Abram heard that his brother was captured, even then he led out his trained men, born of his household, three hundred and eighteen. And they pursued as far as Dan. (MKJV) And when Abram heard that his brother was taken captive, he led forth his trained servants, born in his own house (three hundred and eighteen) and pursued them to Dan. (nas) When Abram heard that his (351) relative [215] had been taken captive, he led [216] out his trained men, born (352) in his house, three hundred and eighteen, and went in pursuit as far as Dan. (353) (NCV) When Abram learned that Lot had been captured, he called out his 318 trained men who had been born in his camp. He led the men and chased the enemy all the way to the town of Dan.

13 (NET.) When Abram heard that his nephew had been taken captive, he mobilized his 318 trained men who had been born in his household, and he pursued the invaders as far as Dan. (NET) When Abram heard that his nephew 33 had been taken captive, he mobilized 34 his 318 trained men who had been born in his household, and he pursued the invaders 35 as far as Dan. 36 (NAB-A) When Abram heard that his nephew had been captured, he mustered three hundred and eighteen of his retainers, born in his house, and went in pursuit as far as Dan. (NIVUK) When Abram heard that his relative had been taken captive, he called out the 318 trained men born in his household and went in pursuit as far as Dan.

14 (NLV) When Abram heard that one of his family had been taken away, he led 318 men who had been born in his house and whom he had taught to fight. They went after them as far as Dan. (nrs) When Abram heard that his nephew had been taken captive, he led forth his trained men, born in his house, three hundred eighteen of them, and went in pursuit as far as Dan. (NWT) Thus A'bram got to hear that his brother had been taken captive. With that he mustered his trained men, three hundred and eighteen slaves born in his household, and went in pursuit up to Dan. (RNKJV) And when Abram heard that his brother was taken captive, he armed his trained servants, born in his own house, three hundred and eighteen, and pursued them unto Dan.

15 (RV) And when Abram heard that his brother was taken captive, he led forth his trained men, born in his house, three hundred and eighteen, and pursued as far as Dan. (TMB) And when Abram heard that his brother was taken captive, he armed his trained servants, born in his own house (three hundred and eighteen), and pursued them unto Dan. (TRC) When Abram heard that his brother was taken, he harnessed his servants born in his own house three hundred and eighteen, and followed till they came at Dan. (Tyndale) When Abram herde that his brother was taken he harnessed his seruantes borne in his owne house.iij. hundred and.xviij. ad folowed tyll they came at Dan.

16 (UPDV) And when Abram heard that his brother was taken captive, he mobilized his trained men, born in his house, three hundred and eighteen, and pursued as far as Dan. (Webster) And when Abram heard that his brother was taken captive, he armed his trained servants, born in his own house, three hundred and eighteen, and pursued them to Dan. (Wycliffe) And whanne Abram hadde herd this thing, that is, Loth his brothir takun, he noumbride his borun seruauntis maad redy thre hundrid and eiytene, and pursuede hem `til to Dan. (YLT) And Abram heareth that his brother hath been taken captive, and he draweth out his trained domestics, three hundred and eighteen, and pursueth unto Dan. وحتى الترجمات القديمة مثل الفلجاتا من القرن ال اربع الميالدي

17 (clvulgate) Quod cum audisset Abram, captum videlicet Lot fratrem suum, numeravit expeditos vernaculos suos trecentos decem et octo: et persecutus est usque Dan. (Vulgate) quod cum audisset Abram captum videlicet Loth fratrem suum numeravit expeditos vernaculos suos trecentos decem et octo et persecutus est eos usque Dan البشيتا من القرن ال اربع وترجمتها للدكتور لم از (Lamsa) And when Abram heard that his nephew had been taken captive, he armed his young men, born in his own house, three hundred and eighteen, and pursued the raiders as far as Dan. بل ايضا السبعينية من القرن الثالث ق م رغم انها تفسيرية ولكن كتبت ايضا دان ولم تشير الي وجود اي تغيير في اي زمن مضى

18 (LXX) ἀκούσας δὲ Αβραμ ὅτι ᾐχμαλώτευται Λωτ ὁ ἀδελφὸς αὐτοῦ, ἠρίθμησεν τοὺς ἰδίους οἰκογενεῖς αὐτοῦ, τριακοσίους δέκα καὶ ὀκτώ, καὶ κατεδίωξεν ὀπίσω αὐτῶν ἕως Δαν. (ABP+) [ 3 having heard G191 1 And G Abram] G* that G3754 [ 4 has been captured G162 1 Lot G* 2 the son G of his brother], G80 G1473 counted out G705 G3588 [ 2 own G native-born servants G his], G1473 three hundred G5145 ten G1176 and G2532 eight. G3638 And G2532 he pursued G2613 unto G2193 Dan. G* (ABP-G+) ακουσας G191 δε G1161 Άβραμ G* οτι G3754 ηχμαλωτευται G162 Λωτ G* ο G3588 αδελφος αυτου G80 G1473 ηριθμησε G705 τους G3588 ιδιους G2398 οικογενεις G αυτου G1473 τριακοσιους G5145 δεκα G1176 και G2532 οκτω G3638 και G2532 κατεδιωξεν G2613 εως G2193 Δαν G* وكل النصوص العبري المتاحة كتبت دان

19 ( HOT )וי שמע אברם וירק אחיו נ שבה כי את חניכיו מאות ו של ש ע שר שמנה ביתו ילידי עד דן וירדף נ שבה H7617 was taken H3588 that כי H87 And when Abram אברם H8085 heard (IHOT+) וי שמע ילידי H3211 H2593 his trained חניכיו H853 את H7324 he armed וירק H251 his brother אחיו captive, ו של ש H7969 H6240 and eighteen, ע שר H8083 and eighteen, שמנה H1004 in his own house, ביתו born H1835 Dan. דן H5704 unto עד H7291 and pursued וירדף H3967 hundred מאות three ( BHS )ו י ש מ ע ו י ר ק אח יו נ ש ב ה כ י אב ר ם א ת ח נ יכ יו י ל יד י ב ית ו ו ש ל ש ע ש ר ש מ נ ה מ א ות ע ד ד ן ו י ר ד ף ( TO ) ו ש מ ע א ר י אב ר ם, מ אה ת ל ת ב ית י ה, י ל יד י ע ול ימ וה י י ת ו ז ר יז א ח וה י; א ש ת ב י ות מ נ ת ד ן. ע ד ור ד ף, ע ס ר, נ ש ב ה כ י אב ר ם ו י ש מ ע ו י ר ק אח יו י ל יד י א ת ח נ יכ יו מ א ות ו ש ל ש ע ש ר ש מ נ ה ב ית ו )WLC( ע ד ד ן ו י ר ד ף Aleppo Codex וירדף מאות ושלש עשר שמנה ביתו ילידי חניכיו את וירק אחיו נשבה כי אברם וישמע יד עד דן

20 נ ש ב ה כ י אב ר ם ו י ר ק אח יו י ל יד י א ת ח נ יכ יו ב ית ו ש מ נ ה ו י ש מ ע TAR Genesis 14:14 ע ד ד ן ו י ר ד ף מ א ות ו ש ל ש ע ש ר נ ש ב ה כ י אב ר ם ו י ש מ ע ו י ר ק אח יו ב ית ו י ל יד י א ת ח נ יכ יו ש מ נ ה WTT Genesis 14:14 ע ד ד ן ו י ר ד ף מ א ות ו ש ל ש ע ש ר وكما نري ان مخطوطة لننج ارد ونص اليبو وغيرهم كلهم اتفقوا ان الكلمة دان فتاكدنا ان الكلمة االصلية هي دان وكما قال قواعد التحليل الداخلي الق ارءة الصعبة هي االصلية ولكن اتي الي نقطة مهمة وهي كيف يكتب موسى اسم مدينة دان في زمن اب ارهيم رغم ان دان لم يولد بعد ارجو الرجوع الي ملف هل كاتب سفر التكوين هو ليس موسي النه كتب اسم القريه دان بدال من اليش تكوين 41: 41

21 وهو شرحت فيه هذا االمر بالتفصيل ولكن هنا باختصار. هذا المكان الذي اسمه دان هو اسم منطقة هو ال عالقة له بدان ابن يعقوب وال بقرية اليش التي تغير اسمها الي دان بعد ان استوطن فيها سبط دان. فدان هو اسم هذه المنطقة قبل دان ابن يعقوب بكثير معني كلمة دان H1835 דן dan BDB Definition: Dan = a judge 1) the 5th son of Jacob, the 1st of Bilhah, Rachel s handmaid (noun proper masculine) 2) the tribe descended from Dan, the son of Jacob (noun proper masculine) 3) a city in Dan, the most northern landmark of Palestine (noun proper locative) وهي تعني يقاضي او يدين

22 وهو اسم قديم معروف ولم يخترعه يعقوب البنه وتم تسمية عدة مدن وقري ومناطق بهذا االسم اذا هو اسم قديم وقد يكون هو اسم المنطقه وبخاصة التي اقام فيها الكنعانيين بمعنى القضاء ونالحظ ان سفر التكوين يقول 41 فلما سمع اب ارم ان اخاه سبي جر غلمانه المتمرنين ولدان بيته ثالث مئة و ثمانية :41 عشر و تبعهم الى دان ولم يقل مدينة دان ولكن تبعهم الي دان اي اسم منطقه وبخاصه ان اب ارهيم لم يكن يرتحل الي مدن ولكنه كان منطلق في المناطق وهو يتتبع جيش ضخم والجيش لم يسكن في مدينه بل اقام في منطقه متسعه النهم اربع جيوش دان. فهما اسمين لشيئين مختلفين فدان التي ذهب اليها جيش اب ارهيم هي منطقة قديمة اسمها من وقت الكنعانيين ولكن اسم مدينة دان الحديث هو اسم مدينة وليس منطقة وهي بعد استيطان سبط فسفر التكوين يشرح لنا اكثر ويوضح ان سفر التكوين يتكلم عن منطقه مختلفه تماما عن مدينة اليش في وتاكيد ذلك ان الرب عندما اري موسي جلعاد ودان سفر التثنية 4 41:

23 و ص ع د م وس ى م ن ع ر ب ات م وآب إ ل ى ج ب ل ن ب و إ ل ى ر أ س ال ف س ج ة ال ذ ي ق ب ال ة أ ر يح ا ف أ ر اه الر ب د ان ج م يع األ ر ض م ن إ ل ى ج ل ع ا د فهنا يتكلم عن انه ارى مناطق وتعرف ان جلعاد في عبر االردن 44 سفر القضاة 5: ج ل ع اد ف ي ع ب ر األ ر د ن س ك ن.و د ان ل م اذ ا اس ت و ط ن ل د ى الس ف ن و أ ش ي ر أ ق ام ع ل ى س اح ل ال ب ح ر و ف ي ف ر ض ه س ك ن. والمنطقه التي ذهب اليها اب ارهيم هي شرق منطقته شمال بيت ايل في سفر التكوين 41 4 جميع هؤالء اجتمعوا متعاهدين الى عمق السديم الذي هو بحر الملح :41 ونري بوضوح اين يقع بحر الملح علي الخريطه ومن هذا ارينا المنطقه ( دان ) التي يتكلم عنها االنجيل هي شمال

24 فهي منطقة كبيرة اما اليش المدينة التي تغير اسمها الي دان علي اسم سبط دان هو فقط مدينة غالبا في منطقة دان او قربها جنوبها وصورتها علي الخريطه

26 وايضا ويقول لنا الكتاب ان اب ارهيم طاردهم من هذه المنطقة الي حوبة قرب دمشق سفر التكوين 41

27 41 :41 فلما سمع اب ارم ان اخاه سبي جر غلمانه المتمرنين ولدان بيته ثالث مئة و ثمانية عشر و تبعهم الى دان 45 و انقسم عليهم ليال هو و عبيده فكسرهم و تبعهم الى حوبة التي عن شمال دمشق :41 وحوبة هي 41 غالبا هي هنا فمنطقة دان اليت تكلم عنها تكوين 41:

28 واهذا وصفها يوسيفوس ( اب ارهيم نزل عليهم في دان التي هي من منابع االردن ويطلق عليها دائرة االردن ) فهنا يتضح ان الكالم عن شيئين مختلفين االولي منطقه والثاني مدينة

29 واليهود يعلمون تماما الفرق بين االثنين 92 وهي :41 فدان الواردة في تكوين 41:41 منطقة هي غير البلد المذكورة في سفر القضاة أقدم من اليش المذكورة في سفر القضاة والدليل على ق دمها هو أن كلمة مؤلفة من»أردن«41:41»أور«كلمتي أي نهر و»دان«أي القضاء. فس م يت الجهة المذكورة في تكوين وفي 4 تثنية 41:»دان«. باسم ويكون أن موسى أطلق اسم دان على جهات كثيرة. أما اليش التي استولى عليها سبط دان وسماها باسم أبيهم فهي غير تلك الجهة. وكان أجدر بالمعترض أن يتحرى ويدرس قبل أن يت هم كتاب اهلل بالتحريف. والمجد هلل دائما

from your Creator طه Ta, Ha. 20:1

from your Creator طه Ta, Ha. 20:1 رسالة : ٢ إن ما أ ن ز ل الق ر آن ل سعادة اإلنسان رسائل رب انية MESSAGE 2: THE QURAN HAS BEEN REVEALED ONLY FOR Divine THE Messages HAPPINESS OF of HUMANITY nurturing from your Creator The way of the Quran